Decentralized Manufacturing: Aleksander Ciszek on Micro Factories and Monetizing IP
Insights
- Aging critical infrastructure is pushing governments toward local micro factories that can produce spare parts the original vendors no longer supply.
- Skilled labor shortages are making highly automated, near-unstaffed production sites a requirement for distributed manufacturing to scale.
- Licensing designs as encrypted data lets OEMs turn a fixed capital asset into a capability available on demand.
Much of the equipment that keeps critical infrastructure running is decades old, and the companies that made its parts are often gone. Aleksander Ciszek, CEO and Founder of 3YOURMIND, sat down with Jeff Kavanaugh, Head of the Infosys Knowledge Institute, during the World Economic Forum's Advanced Manufacturing & Supply Chains Forum in San Francisco. They discussed how governments and MRO operators are answering that problem with networks of small, local production hubs. 3YOURMIND started in 3D printing, but its micro factories can house almost any production technology, and Ciszek argues the real value sits in the software: a digital inventory of qualified parts, so a fix engineered and tested at one site never has to be reinvented at another. He also makes the case that the people maintaining equipment often design better parts than the originals, and that the OEM business model of profiting from breakdowns will have to give way to what he calls the Spotify of manufacturing. The result, in his framing, is decentralized production with centralized intelligence, where every failure in the network becomes knowledge the whole system can use.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
I'm Jeff Kavanaugh with the Infosys Knowledge Institute at the World Economic Forum's Advanced Manufacturing Supply Chain Forum here in San Francisco. And today I'm joined by Aleksander.
Aleksander Ciszek:
Thank you for having me. I'm Aleksander Ciszek from the company 3YOURMIND and we are in the space of decentralized manufacturing. What we do as a company is we basically work mostly with governments, so we are oftentimes involved in private-public partnerships where we build generalized micro factories that can produce not everything but almost everything. And the purpose for this is to be able to react fast on geopolitical disruption or catastrophes, natural catastrophes or these kinds of things. So very small factories that can build a variety of things.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
Close to the point of need.
Aleksander Ciszek:
Why do governments work with us? Because they want to maintain critical infrastructure and they want to maintain some critical equipment. Oftentimes they need to get spare parts. Oftentimes they don't have access to those spare parts anymore because the vendors are out of business because this is all old equipment.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
Oh yeah, it's old equipment. And you're thinking about what a machine tool, I'm not saying welding, but is it more like a drill?
Aleksander Ciszek:
All kinds of technologies. Our background as a company is we started off with 3D printing. This is why we started to think that way, right? Because you don't have the tooling costs, you have design freedom. But it is not limited to additive technologies, to 3D printing. Into these micro factories you could put any type of technology. A very interesting use case is that we do with one of the governments in Europe where they have created a bunch of different production facilities because they have a huge need for repairment, for spare parts. They cannot get those spare parts anymore and they have the right to repair, so they do everything they can to ensure that their critical infrastructure is operational. And one thing that kind of fits into all the discussions of today basically every user or every facility that needs to maintain some equipment becomes an innovation center. So it's basically democratizing innovation, because suddenly the people who are operating the machines, who need the spare parts, they cannot get the spare parts. They invent new solutions. But oftentimes those new parts and new solutions are better than the original ones. I call it democratizing innovation. But we could call it in a different way.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
This speeds up also the I think, the innovation process and it should be interesting for the OEMs.
Aleksander Ciszek:
At this stage I think the OEMs have still a little bit of a barrier in terms of communication, which we also try to break.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
What is it you actually deliver?
Aleksander Ciszek:
It's a whole system. First of all it's this decentralized network of these production hubs, production facilities.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
So you already have an existing hub they can tap into that might be in their town?
Aleksander Ciszek:
Yes, but oftentimes these are built from scratch as well. If the customer is a government, then it's usually halls, not mobile units, not containerized units, but halls that are built up and they are there. Or this is like using old facilities.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
And do you buy someone else's equipment and put it in?
Aleksander Ciszek:
Yeah, and we are responsible also for the startup of the machine, the maintenance of the machine running. We do the system integration. However, I think the most important part and let's say the secret sauce to make it successful is the software layer that we have created. If you think about those production hubs and the use case of spare parts, so you might have the same products or the same systems that need to be maintained, and you might need the same spare parts. But what is already a big value is that if in one place the part is reverse engineered and even made better and tested and functional and implemented into the system, then why would someone else do the same work and reinvent the wheel? So we have created a digital inventory of qualified spare parts for the customer. So everyone in the network of the customer can look at those spare parts and then use them.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
You would think you mentioned government that aerospace is like that because I've worked with aerospace manufacturers before not that many years ago that are opening up ten-inch-thick books going through designs. And so those are parts that have been flying around for thirty years in some cases. You know, refurbishing, remanufacturing engines, you know, turning them over again, MRO types of things.
Aleksander Ciszek:
This is exactly the MRO customer is the typical customer that we work with.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
What is your end game?
Aleksander Ciszek:
So the end game is that production is localized and automated. If our vision is to have decentralized micro factories, let's say all around the country, then very naturally we need to address the talent issue, right? So first of all this learning curve on how to let's say operate machines, how to design parts, how to optimize for manufacturing in different technologies is something where, which we address through on one hand training but also oftentimes through already certified use cases that of parts that have been produced. So people learn by just learning from others and looking at examples of parts.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
This micro factory, would it have one employee, two employees?
Aleksander Ciszek:
Ideally in the future, let's say between zero and one. Right now it's usually a couple of people. But I think this automation process, trying to find a way where there is almost no one working, is also needed because we are missing skilled labor at this stage already. And it's probably going to be even worse. It's not about saving costs necessarily. There is a huge need. So we see ourselves as, let's say, if you look at the aspect of ensuring that in this decentralized world the parts are produced with the right quality, and the IP owners are also receiving their fair share for providing that data, we see ourselves in a very simplified way as the Spotify of manufacturing. We enable the OEMs to share their data. And instead of producing the part, they just monetize the data, and the end customer is producing, and we are ensuring that the data goes directly in an encrypted way.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
What's a challenge for companies that are going through this? What's the big challenge they have that you might have an answer for?
Aleksander Ciszek:
I think there is a big mindset challenge. Where I'm observing a big mindset switch need is in the space of the OEM and MRO relationship. Because at this stage the OEMs and the suppliers they have a kind of comfortable situation in which they sell specific equipment and if this equipment is broken, then it's an opportunity for new business. They replace the whole whatever is broken and charge you a lot. This is not necessarily what always the MRO wants. They want to extend the lifetime of whatever they buy. And I also believe that there is an opportunity for the OEMs, not necessarily to provide and monetize the parts or the systems that they have been selling so far but just sharing their IP. And we can come in here because we are able to ensure that all this intellectual property that the OEM creates can be monetized without necessarily all these production costs that are needed to convert the digital data into physical data.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
Because you're creating what used to be a fixed cost for them into a variable cost
Aleksander Ciszek:
Yeah, yeah.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
and a capability. So it's a capability on demand whereas before it was a major fixed asset capital decision.
Aleksander Ciszek:
From the MRO perspective, the way how we like to let's say pitch this new approach or this new capability is that we say, look, if you implement this system then you gain basically a decentralized production capability, but a centralized intelligence. Just to explain a little bit more what do we mean by the decentralized capability, it's on one hand the decentralized production capability because you have the machines in a decentralized network. However, you gain from this decentralized network the knowledge about what breaks, so you can react faster, you can react better, and you can also create a centralized, let's say, repository of qualified parts that then can be sent to those.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
New IP in a way.
Aleksander Ciszek:
Yeah.
Jeff Kavanaugh:
Thanks, Aleksander, for a very stimulating discussion. This is a good example of what advanced manufacturing looks like, I was talking about the Lighthouse Network, the Lighthouse operating system, and the future of manufacturing overall.